Digital regulation still not joined-up and effective enough – Lords committee

Systems are not rigorous or accountable enough to address regulatory gaps and overlaps, according to the House of Lords Communications and Digital Committee which says that better processes as well as regulators, industry and experts working more closely together are needed to deal with emerging challenges such as artificial intelligence advances.

A new Digital Regulation Co-operation Forum (DRCF) is “a small step” but a lack of overarching coordination and oversight of regulatory objectives remains, the committee says in a report published today (13 December).

While welcoming the DRCF’s collaborative work so far, the committee is concerned that it lacks robust systems to coordinate objectives and to sort out potential conflicts between different regulators as the workload expands. More measures are needed to boost the DRCF’s long-term effectiveness and accountability, the committee believes.

The committee recommends that an independent chair of the DRCF be appointed to resolve conflicts between regulators and to be accountable to Parliament.

Lord Gilbert, chair of the committee, said:

“Persistent challenges remain that the regulatory system is insufficiently equipped to confront.

“We called for more joined-up regulation and more resources as far back as 2019 and although the DRCF is a step in the right direction it doesn’t meet the challenges we face.

“We are concerned that not all regulators with digital interests and expertise have a seat at the table.

“Sharing information between regulators, advisory bodies, government, industry and experts needs to be enhanced to avoid duplication and ensure that the greatest range of perspectives feed into regulation.”

The committee wants to see a new committee of MPs and peers set up to oversee digital regulation.

Lord Gilbert added:

“Given the pace of technological change and its impact across society and the economy, there is a notable gap in Parliamentary oversight.”